The Questioning Spirit

By Arthur Hugh Clough

Lyric Poem
    The human spirits saw I on a day,     Sitting and looking each a different way;     And hardly tasking, subtly questioning,     Another spirit went around the ring     To each and each: and as he ceased his say,     Each after each, I heard them singly sing,     Some querulously high, some softly, sadly low,     We know not, what avails to know?     We know not, wherefore need we know?     This answer gave they still unto his suing,     We know not, let us do as we are doing.     Dost thou not know that these things only seem?     I know not, let me dream my dream.     Are dust and ashes fit to make a treasure?     I know not, let me take my pleasure.     What shall avail the knowledge thou hast sought?     I know not, let me think my thought.     What is the end of strife?     I know not, let me live my life.     How many days or eer thou meanst to move?     I know not, let me love my love.     Were not things old once new?     I know not, let me do as others do.     And when the rest were over past,     I know not, I will do my duty, said the last.     Thy duty do? rejoined the voice,     Ah, do it, do it, and rejoice;     But shalt thou then, when all is done,     Enjoy a love, embrace a beauty     Like these, that may be seen and won     In life, whose course will then be run;     Or wilt thou be where there is none?     I know not, I will do my duty.     And taking up the word around, above, below,     Some querulously high, some softly, sadly low,     We know not, sang they all, nor ever need we know!     We know not, sang they, what avails to know?     Whereat the questioning spirit, some short space,     Though unabashed, stood quiet in his place.     But as the echoing chorus died away     And to their dreams the rest returned apace,     By the one spirit I saw him kneeling low,     And in a silvery whisper heard him say:     Truly, thou knowst not, and thou needst not know;     Hope only, hope thou, and believe alway;     I also know not, and I need not know,     Only with questionings pass I to and fro,     Perplexing these that sleep, and in their folly     Imbreeding doubt and sceptic melancholy;     Till that, their dreams deserting, they with me     Come all to this true ignorance and thee.

Share & Analyze This Poem

Spread the beauty of poetry or dive deeper into analysis

Analyze This Poem

Discover the literary devices, structure, and deeper meaning

Copy to Clipboard

Save this poem for personal use or sharing offline

Share the Love of Poetry
More Poems
More Lyric Poems
Daily Poem

Poem Details

Language: English
Keywords: Public Domain
Source: Public Domain Collection
Rights/Permissions: Public Domain
Analysis & Notes:
Arthur Hugh Clough's poem "The Questioning Spirit" is a meditation on the nature of knowledge, doubt, and human existence. The poem examines the limits of human understanding and the different ways people respond to the uncertainty of life. Through the interplay of various voices and a questioning spirit, Clough reflects on the tension between the pursuit of knowledge and the acceptance of ignorance.

Structure and Form
The poem is written in a loose iambic rhythm with a conversational, almost musical flow. Clough employs alternating voices—some high, some low, as he describes them—to create a chorus of perspectives, each expressing a different attitude toward knowledge and life. The repetition of phrases like “We know not” emphasizes the recurring theme of uncertainty and resignation.

The poem’s dialogue form, where the questioning spirit interacts with different individuals, lends it a dramatic quality, making it feel like a philosophical conversation or debate. The overall tone is reflective and contemplative, yet tinged with sadness and skepticism as the spirits reveal their various responses to the existential questions posed.

Themes
The Limits of Human Knowledge: The central theme of the poem is the limitation of human understanding. Each spirit expresses ignorance, responding to the questioning spirit with variations of “I know not.” This refrain suggests a collective acknowledgment that there are some things that human beings simply cannot know. The recurring phrase reflects a kind of existential humility, a recognition that life’s ultimate questions—about the meaning of existence, love, duty, and death—remain unanswered.

Resignation and Contentment: While some of the spirits seem troubled by their ignorance, others appear resigned, even content with their lack of knowledge. Lines like “I know not, let me dream my dream” and “I know not, let me live my life” show how people often choose to live in a state of acceptance, preferring not to question too deeply and instead find satisfaction in their daily lives. Clough explores this tension between active questioning and passive acceptance, suggesting that, for many, ignorance is a refuge from the discomfort of uncertainty.

Duty vs. Desire: One of the final voices stands out by responding to the questioning spirit with, “I will do my duty.” This spirit suggests a moral resolution in the face of uncertainty, choosing to focus on fulfilling one’s responsibilities rather than worrying about the unknowable. The poem contrasts this sense of duty with the earlier voices, which are more concerned with personal pleasure or dreaming. The questioning spirit challenges this resolve, asking whether doing one’s duty will lead to fulfillment in life or in some afterlife. Still, the spirit responds with determination, reaffirming the decision to do their duty regardless of the outcome.

Skepticism and Melancholy: The “questioning spirit” is a figure of skepticism, going around the ring of spirits and sowing doubt. This figure represents the intellectual impulse to question, probe, and challenge accepted ideas, which often leads to a deeper sense of uncertainty or "sceptic melancholy." While the spirits may find comfort in ignorance, the questioning spirit finds purpose in creating doubt, implying that human thought is restless and unable to fully settle on definitive answers. This skepticism can breed dissatisfaction, but it is also a vital part of the human condition.

Faith and Hope: By the end of the poem, the questioning spirit seems to adopt a quieter, more reflective stance, whispering, “Hope only, hope thou, and believe alway.” This suggests that while knowledge may be elusive, there is still room for hope and belief. Faith, in this context, is not necessarily religious but a way of navigating life’s uncertainties. The spirit’s final words imply that hope is the only thing that can sustain humans in the face of their ignorance. The spirit’s role is to keep humans questioning, yet also to remind them that certainty is not necessary for a meaningful existence.

Imagery and Symbols
The Ring of Spirits: The spirits sitting in a ring, each looking in a different direction, symbolize the diversity of human thought and the various ways people confront life’s big questions. Their scattered perspectives suggest that each person focuses on their own concerns, oblivious to the larger, shared reality of their ignorance. The ring itself could symbolize the cyclical nature of human inquiry, where questions lead to more questions rather than definitive answers.

The Questioning Spirit: The questioning spirit is a personification of doubt and intellectual curiosity. This figure’s role is to go around and challenge the other spirits, asking them to reflect on the meaning of their lives and actions. The spirit embodies the philosophical impulse to question existence, knowledge, and truth, yet by the end of the poem, even the questioning spirit admits to not knowing the answers.

Dreams: The recurring mention of dreams represents escapism and the preference to remain within the realm of personal fantasies rather than confronting difficult truths. Phrases like “let me dream my dream” convey how many people choose to focus on their immediate pleasures and desires, rather than seeking deeper meaning or questioning the nature of existence.

Duty: Duty stands as a counterpoint to personal desire and pleasure. The spirit who focuses on doing their duty exemplifies the idea that moral responsibility can provide purpose, even in the face of ignorance. Clough raises the question of whether fulfilling one’s duty offers ultimate fulfillment or merely serves as a way of avoiding deeper existential questions.

Tone
The tone of "The Questioning Spirit" is reflective, skeptical, and at times melancholic. The poem explores deep philosophical issues but maintains an air of resignation, as the voices in the poem repeatedly express their acceptance of ignorance. There is a sense of sadness in the spirits’ resignation, as they acknowledge their inability to know or understand life’s deeper meanings. However, by the end, the tone shifts slightly towards hope, as the questioning spirit suggests that while answers may be elusive, hope and belief can provide solace.

Exploring Lyric Poetry

Lyric poetry is a powerful and intimate form of expression, characterized by its focus on the personal emotions and thoughts of the poet. Often musical in nature, lyric poems resonate with readers through their vivid language and rhythmic flow, capturing moments of intense feeling.

Here are some key characteristics that define lyric poetry:

  • Expressive Language: Lyric poems use rich and evocative language to convey deep emotions, often painting a vivid picture of the poet's inner world.
  • Personal Perspective: Typically written in the first person, these poems offer a window into the poet's personal experiences, thoughts, and reflections.
  • Musicality: Lyric poems often feature a rhythmic structure, with meter and rhyme that give them a song-like quality, enhancing the emotional impact.

From ancient odes to contemporary free verse, lyric poetry remains a beloved and enduring form, celebrated for its ability to articulate the nuances of human emotion in a way that resonates deeply with readers.