The Iconoclastic Rustic And The Apropos Acorn

By Guy Wetmore Carryl

    Reposing 'neath some spreading trees,     A populistic bumpkin     Amused himself by offering these     Reflections on a pumpkin:     "I would not, if the choice were mine,     Grow things like that upon a vine,     For how imposing it would be     If pumpkins grew upon a tree."     Like other populists, you'll note,     Of views enthusiastic,     He'd learned by heart, and said by rote     A creed iconoclastic;     And in his dim, uncertain sight     Whatever wasn't must be right,     From which it follows he had strong     Convictions that what was, was wrong.     As thus he sat beneath an oak     An acorn fell abruptly     And smote his nose: whereat he spoke     Of acorns most corruptly.     "Great Scott!" he cried. "The Dickens!" too,     And other authors whom he knew,     And having duly mentioned those,     He expeditiously arose.     Then, though with pain he nearly swooned,     He bathed his organ nasal     With arnica, and soothed the wound     With extract of witch hazel;     And surely we may well excuse     The victim if he changed his views:     "If pumpkins fell from trees like that,"     He murmured, "Where would I be at?"     Of course it's wholly clear to you     That when these words he uttered     He proved conclusively he knew     Which side his bread was buttered;     And, if this point you have not missed,     You'll learn to love this populist,     The only one of all his kind     With sense enough to change his mind.     THE MORAL: In the early spring     A pumpkin-tree would be a thing     Most gratifying to us all,     But how about the early fall?

Share & Analyze This Poem

Spread the beauty of poetry or dive deeper into analysis

Analyze This Poem

Discover the literary devices, structure, and deeper meaning

Create Image

Transform this poem into a beautiful shareable image

Copy to Clipboard

Save this poem for personal use or sharing offline


Share the Love of Poetry

Poem Details

Language: English
Keywords: Public Domain
Source: Public Domain Collection
Rights/Permissions: Public Domain

Analysis & Notes:
This clever and whimsical poem uses humor and a folksy tone to explore themes of myopia, conviction, and the acceptance of change. The narrative revolves around a "populistic bumpkin" who, in his limited perspective, questions why pumpkins don't grow on trees. The poet uses the bumpkin's reflections as a light-hearted critique of individuals who challenge the status quo without fully considering the potential consequences.

The poem's structure underscores its narrative arc, gradually building from the bumpkin's initial reflections to his painful realization, courtesy of an acorn, that pumpkins on trees might not be such a good idea. The poet effectively employs a mix of rhyme and rhythm to maintain a lively, engaging pace throughout, and the use of casual, colloquial language amplifies the poem's accessible, humorous tone.

A standout literary device in this poem is the use of the falling acorn as a symbol of sudden insight or realization. The bumpkin's swift change of heart, prompted by his painful encounter with the acorn, highlights the poem's thematic exploration of the importance of experience in shaping perspective.

The poem concludes with a moral, which serves as a reminder of the potential pitfalls of short-sightedness. This ending brings the poem's themes full circle, reinforcing the importance of considering potential outcomes before advocating for change. Through its amusing narrative and thoughtful exploration of human nature, this poem offers a lighthearted yet insightful commentary on the wisdom of embracing change without due consideration.

Understanding Fables

A fable is a timeless form of storytelling, typically featuring animals as characters that embody human traits, all while conveying a moral lesson. These short narratives have been used throughout history to impart wisdom, offering insights that remain relevant across generations.


Fables stand out for their simplicity and clarity, often concluding with a lesson that is easy to understand and remember. Here are some defining characteristics:

  • Animal Characters: The main characters are often animals that represent human behaviors and characteristics, making the stories both engaging and relatable.
  • Concise Narrative: Fables are brief and focused, with each story centering around a single event or interaction that leads to a moral conclusion.
  • Moral Lesson: The purpose of a fable is to teach a lesson, which is usually stated clearly at the end, offering practical advice or ethical guidance.

From Aesop's ancient tales to modern adaptations, fables continue to be a powerful tool for education and moral reflection, resonating with audiences of all ages.